Solution video
OpenStax College Physics, Chapter 10, Problem 39 (Problems & Exercises)
Calculator Screenshots
Comments
Shouldnt the final momentum include the momentum of the linear velocity of the child. He starts at rest so not only is the moment of inertia changed but momentum is also taken from having to speed up the child. Am I correct in this observation?
Hello dr#, thank you for the question. Since the child is moving in a circle their momentum is modelled as "angular momentum", not linear momentum. The velocity of the child is continually changing direction, so it isn't useful to think of the velocity as "linear", although you're correct if you're thinking that their instantaneous velocity is tangential to the circle. Angular momentum is conserved independently from linear momentum. To say "momentum is taken from having to speed up the child" sounds like the focus is on the momentum of the merry-go-round - however it's better to consider the momentum of the system, which consists of both the child and merry-go-round. The angular momentum of the system is conserved, and this is the important concept of this type of question. While the angular momentum of the merry-go-round is indeed reduced, the reduction is compensated for exactly by the increase in angular momentum of the child. Having the total angular momentum of the system stay the same is what it means to say angular momentum of the system is conserved.
Hope this helps,
Shaun